The highly anticipated release of MLB The Show 25 brings back the ever-popular Diamond Dynasty mode, where you build your ultimate team by collecting cards of current stars and legendary players. This guide highlights some of the best Diamond Dynasty cards and lineups available in March 2025.
Recommended Videos: Best Diamond Dynasty Cards in MLB The Show 25 Right Now
While your starting lineup in March won't necessarily be your end-game team in MLB The Show 25, these cards offer excellent value and performance right now. Let's dive into some top picks:
Team Affinity James Wood

Washington Nationals' rising star, James Wood, is the Team Affinity reward. Unlocking him requires effort, but his consistent contact against both lefties and righties makes it worthwhile. His power is also impressive for a corner outfielder, making him a solid mid-lineup hitter.
Pipeline Program Walker Jenkins

While Walker Jenkins is a center fielder, his exceptional hitting makes playing him out of position justifiable. He boasts strong contact and power, and though his speed isn't extraordinary, he'll still manage to leg out his fair share of hits.
20th Anniversary Clayton Kershaw

A perennial MLB The Show ace, Clayton Kershaw returns in the Anniversary Series with a formidable arsenal, including his signature 12-6 curveball. His relatively low market price makes him an excellent budget option.
Live Series Emmanuel Clase

Dominant relief pitching is crucial in Diamond Dynasty, and Emmanuel Clase delivers. While his pitch mix isn't overly extensive, his high-velocity fastball and devastating slider make him a shutdown closer.
Related: Best Pitching Settings for MLB The Show 25
Best March 2025 MLB The Show 25 Diamond Dynasty Lineup
Confidence is key in Ranked Diamond Dynasty games. This lineup, built with realistically obtainable cards (excluding high-end Live Series players like Aaron Judge or Shohei Ohtani), will help you crush the competition:
- 20th Anniversary Elly De La Cruz (SS)
- Pipeline Program Walker Jenkins (LF)
- Prospect Pipeline Jordan Lawlar (3B)
- Team Affinity James Wood (RF)
- Spring Breakout Max Clark (CF)
- 20th Anniversary David Wright (DH)
- Team Affinity Craig Biggio (C)
- Spring Breakout JJ Wetherholt (2B)
- Prospect Pipeline Nick Kurtz (1B)
- 20th Anniversary Clayton Kershaw (SP)
- Live Series Felix Bautista (RP)
- Live Series Emmanuel Clase (CP)
These are some of the best MLB The Show 25 Diamond Dynasty cards and lineups for March 2025. For more tips and strategies, check out our guide on whether to go to college or go pro in Road to the Show.
MLB The Show 25 is now available in Early Access on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.